Classic Cape Cod with Loads of Character Located in the Vibrant

Eken Park Neighborhood

2538 Commercial Ave

ACCEPTED OFFER!!!

5 bedrooms / 2 bath / + office
2,141 finished sq ft / .12 aces / 1-car detached garage
Rooftop deck / partially fenced backyard

460,000

All offers due May 27, 2025 @ midnight
Seller offering 2.5% of purchase price to Buyer’s Firm for Buyer’s Brokerage fees.

 

Timeless Charm Meets Thoughtful Upgrades

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 1950s Cape Cod tucked into the heart of Madison’s vibrant Eken Park neighborhood—where vintage charm, thoughtful updates, and an unbeatable location come together to create something special. From warm wood floors to arched doorways, this home offers a sense of history paired with functionality for today’s lifestyle.

First Impressions That Last

Step inside and feel immediately welcomed by the home’s enduring charm. Graceful arched doorways and rich wood floors set the tone—flowing throughout every room without a single stitch of carpet. On the main level, original doors and vintage hardware reflect the home’s mid-century roots, while upstairs, solid core doors add a sense of quiet luxury and privacy. Thoughtful details like classic 1950s-bathroom tilework and original doorknobs bring timeless character to every corner.

In a classic home where closet space can be scarce, this one delivers: a dedicated coat closet welcomes you in the entryway, and a linen closet near the main-level bathroom provides convenient storage where you need it most.

A Versatile & Stylish Main Level

The main level offers three flexible bedrooms—one with peaceful views of the backyard, making it perfect for a cozy sunroom, creative studio, or home office. A full bath on this floor allows for easy access for guests or family members.

The kitchen blends original cabinetry and hardware with smart, high-quality updates. In 2024–2025, the space received a brand-new GE range, refrigerator, and dishwasher, freshly painted cabinets, and a new kitchen sink positioned beneath a window that overlooks the beautifully landscaped backyard.  A custom-built island provides seamless storage and additional cabinet space.

Other improvements include:

  • GE Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher (2024)

  • Kitchen Faucet (2025)

  • Countertops (2015)

  • Hardwood floor installation (2013)

  • Upgraded lighting — recessed cans, outlets, and ceiling fan (2014)

  • Kitchen RO water filtration system (2015)

A Stunning & Spacious Second Floor

Head upstairs to the surprise of the home—a full second-floor suite thoughtfully remodeled in 2019. The expansive 17' x 12' primary bedroom features refinished hardwood floors, high-end Renewal by Andersen® windows that flood the room with natural light, and a luxurious walk-in California Closet system designed for smart, stylish storage.

The spa-like upstairs bath includes a beautifully tiled tub surround, a double-sink vanity, custom Wisconsin-made cabinetry, and striking polygon tile flooring. An additional upstairs bedroom offers more flexibility—guest room, den, or office—and leads to a private 14' x 10' rooftop deck with stairs down to the backyard. Whether you're sipping morning coffee or hosting friends under the stars, this space is a rare gem.

Looking for added flexibility or investment potential? The second floor could easily function as a separate rental suite, thanks to its private layout and multiple access points.

Thoughtful Lower Level with Storage and Flexibility

An exterior side entry door provides convenient access to both the kitchen and the basement—as you enter. Head straight ahead to the kitchen, or take the stairs down to the lower level, where you'll find a thoughtfully designed mudroom area just to the left. This practical drop zone features built-in shelving under the stairs, a bench, and coat hooks (both the bench and coats hooks are negotiable)—making it easy to stay organized.

From there, the basement opens to a finished rec room, an enclosed laundry area with brand-new GE washer and dryer (2024), a cozy bonus room ideal for a home office or creative space, and a private, spacious storage room to keep seasonal items, tools, or gear out of sight but easily accessible.

Significant improvements make the lower level both comfortable and functional, including:

  • Dual-zone furnace and AprilAire system (2020)

  • GE washer and dryer (2024)

  • Finished basement, including baseboard heat in two rooms (2017)

  • Sump pump and perimeter drain tile system (2014)

  • Spray foam insulation in sill boxes (2014)

  • Carpet & vinyl flooring (2015)

  • Rebuilt stairwell, enclosed laundry, and additional shelving (2015)

Outdoor Living, Smart Systems & Peace of Mind

The backyard was professionally designed by MaraLee Olson Design Studios and reimagined by Schönheit Gardens (2015–2016) to support chemical-free landscaping, with lush plantings and beautiful hardscaping. Enjoy it from your rooftop deck or the sunny yard below. The 1-car detached garage (17' x 16') provides space for your car and storage for bikes, tools, and more.

Major exterior updates include:

  • New house and garage roofs + gutters (Ridge Top Exteriors, 2024)

  • Flat roof replacement on balcony and front entrance (2018)

  • New storm doors at all exterior doors (2021)

  • Balcony safety railing (2010)

  • Main level bathroom fan (2025)

  • Ceiling to floor insulation from crawl space and the perimeter of the exterior foundation of the back bedroom addition (2011 & 2013)

  • Insulation work was done per an energy audit by American Home Consultants now Zander (2018-2019) including:

    • -Dense packed cellulose insulation over the rear addition, exterior wall of dormer and all open sloped ceilings.

    • Open joist insulation (R-50) with blown in loose fill cellulose and installation of wood barrier in the attic and attic access opening.

    • Fire rated Thermax foam board, foil tape, EPDM weather stripping at perimeter of attic hatch access.

    • Outer wall top plate sealing and ceiling gaps with a minimum 1” layer of two part sprayed on urethane foam.

Other highlights include:

  • Smart Ecobee thermostat (2019)

  • Security camera system (Nelly’s Security, 2017)

  • CAT 6 ethernet ports in both offices and living room

  • Full interior repainting, plaster repair (2014–2025)

  • Whole-home insulation upgrades (2018–2019)

  • Hunter Douglas blinds in most rooms, including top town bottom up blinds in bedrooms for additional privacy (2017)

  • All work by licensed contractors with proper permits and final approvals

Experience the Charm of Eken Park

This walkable neighborhood is known for its vibrant community, tree-lined streets, and a variety of locally owned restaurants, coffee shops, and other favorite spots. You're just steps from beloved spots like Tip Top Tavern, Young Blood Beer Company, Ogden’s North Street Diner, and North Street Cabaret, a hub for live music and neighborhood events. Parks like Eken Park and Demetral Field offer green space for play, picnics, and peaceful walks.

Locally Loved Cafés, Restaurants & Shops

  • Bloom Bake Shop, Domestique Coffee, and Young Blood Beer Company – all at 557 North St

  • Tip Top Tavern, a long-standing neighborhood staple

  • Ogden’s North Street Diner – cozy breakfasts and classic fare

  • The North Street Cabaret – your go-to for live music and local events

  • The Bubbling Tea Pot (incredible bubble tea!), 2611 E Johnson St

  • Tandem Press Art Gallery – hosting Friday Night Jazz, exhibitions, and art fairs

  • Bear and Bottle, Patricia’s Market Mexican Restaurant, Ancora Coffee, Lola's Hi/Lo Lounge, and It’s Good For You – all on N Sherman Ave

  • Tacos El Capi, Moka Coffee, and Banzo (beloved Mediterranean spot) nearby on E Washington Ave and Sherman Ave

  • The Bodgery Makerspace – a creative hub for DIY enthusiasts

  • Madison College Truax and Commercial Ave Campuses

  • Pick ‘n Save for everyday grocery needs

Parks & Natural Spaces

  • Eken Park – featuring brand new playground equipment including natural play elements, a basketball court, and open field

  • Demetral Park – with green space, a volleyball court, outdoor fitness gear, modern shelter, and more

  • Carpenter-Ridgeway Park and Forest – accessible via the Starkweather Creek path, offering forest trails, a labyrinth, and sports field

  • Burroughs Park on Lake Mendota

  • Washington Manor Park – just off N Oak St

This is more than a home—it’s a gateway to a thriving community where old meets new, and every street feels like part of your neighborhood story. Whether you're looking for a forever home or an investment with flexibility, this Eken Park gem is ready for its next chapter.

Click ON Image to view VIDEO tour